5 Comments
User's avatar
Geostack's avatar

The claim that Britain is "Russia’s primary opponent” is controversial. If we talk about Putin’s Russia, Putin doesn’t consider Britain and even Europe as independent players. Talks on Ukraine clearly demonstrate it. Russia is unlikely to view Britain as a primary military goal or threat. However, it doesn’t mean that Russian threat doesn’t exist - it needs to be viewed in a broader context of European security.

Mìodrag Kojadínović (鄺·妙讜)'s avatar

The image used as illustration is silly.

Not only are the countries represented in a hugely disparate perspective (Russia is as big as 70 UKs put together, not just twice as big), but also bears do live in Russia, though perhaps not as the main or top of the chain predator (that would probably be tigers), while lions in Britain are only in a handful of zoos.

Monnina's avatar

‘When was the last time you heard a political leader offering a long-term vision of the future that was positive?’ Dr Robert Johnson.

This sums up the greatest current threat to Britain’s future security. Lack of any coherent and honest communal political vision. Until there is a shared cross party longterm political vision offered by the British state that all can fully enter into with hearts and minds, any kinetic of hybrid conflict with hostile foreign powers is already lost before it’s begun.

LudwigF's avatar

This really is a lot of warmongering nonsense - the idea that Europe should militarise itself into bankruptcy because of a non-existent threat of invasion from Russia is utterly preposterous.

How’s this for a better idea: articulate a coherent and pragmatic strategy in terms of exactly what we’re trying to achieve; stop firing missiles at Moscow; engage in some old-fashioned diplomacy and help Ukraine cut the best deal possible.

David Marshland's avatar

“a non-existent threat of invasion from Russia”?

The Georgians, Moldovans, Ukrainians and other states bordering Russia might disagree?

Insofar as the article refers to an invasion of the UK, it’s dismissed as improbable. But as we’re seeing with Russian refineries and unexplained fires at various Western European arms factories, you don’t need boots on the ground to disrupt a country’s defences.

The UK is an island and we’re already seeing Russian vessels clearly undertaking underwater activities around us. Why? How long before anchors start being dragged through our off-shore infrastructure?

Russia is massively bigger geographically, but most of it is empty and undefended as Ukraine repeatedly proves. But as an industrial and economic power Russia is demonstrably the weaker, relying on smuggled sanctions busting components to make missiles work.

Remember that for all the invincible power projected by Nazi Germany, Britain’s arms industry was outperforming it from day one of WW2. Russia depended on US-supplied trucks to keep its troops moving. Russia takes forever to actual volume manufacture of its Red Square parade wonder arms. The Armata tank is approaching 20 years since it was announced. It’s still not in frontline service. Tanks dating from the 60s are being resuscitated instead.

Rely on diplomacy with Putin!

He smirkingly admits lies. The little green men/Speznatz who invaded Crimea? He definitely had no plans to invade Ukraine, until his tanks crossed over the frontier. The murders carried out on UK soil?

Chamberlain may have come back from Munich with a piece of paper, but as Chancellor and PM he built up the RAF’s ability to withstand the Luftwaffe. He didn’t rely just on the piece of paper, as ironically did the Russians with the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact