Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Zamshed Harun's avatar

I take the point that authority, not connectivity, is the real test, and the mission command section makes that case well. The trust an ally has two parts. The second half: not only where its authority begins and ends, but why it should believe what the web recommends (targets/intelligence valid & viable?). ASGARD-class decision support carries assurance obligations the infrastructure debate has not yet named: who accredits the models, to what standard, how a recommendation is challenged after an error (or, can we rescind a target as fast as we identify it), and who answers for it. That question decides the Maven comparison too. A sovereign British node positioned as the European hedge will be chosen for its assurance regime as much as its sovereignty; without a testing and accountability story an ally can inspect, it is a second dependency with different packaging. So I would put the question to HMG slightly differently: not only whether the web is designed to be the hedge, but what assurance travels with it when a partner plugs in.

Ready for more?