Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cal A. Urquhart's avatar

The German armed forces are in a dismal state but the public seems to realize that and recognize a need for change. I think the UK public is a bit further behind.

Completely agree about the financial situation. Germany wants to buy a military. Money helps a lot, but it cannot fix every problem. Some things need time. Worse is that for the next several years, Germany will be buying massive amounts of American (and Israeli) weapons as they build their own domestic industries. That means a long tail of spare parts, munitions, service contracts and software updates. Massive demand after the war in Iran makes these systems highly subject to price inflation.

From my view at a distance, it looks like the MoD and the treasury have been locked in a wrestling spiral for years. Like in many countries, the MoD is bad at procurement. There are several reasons, but perhaps the biggest is financial. The demand placed on them exceeds the budget and so cost estimates are always aggressive. When the inevitable overruns happen, orders get cut and construction delayed by years. Hull counts are forever measured and almost always lose against retaining the workforce of engineers, shipbuilders, etc. that are needed. In comparison, I think the treasury sees an MoD that lies to them every year; they are perpetually over budget and always behind schedule; they will regularly invest billions in projects that fail, etc. In some ways it seems they are both right and yet still at fault.

OkamsRazor's avatar

I think the author’s are viewing the German defence sector with rose tinted glasses. Recent German internal coverage shows the German army and navy with significant problems in all areas including recruitment and maintenance of weapons systems and obviously in procurement. The fact that they have decided to loosen fiscal rules and throw money at procurement doesn’t solve underlying problems. A fantasy armed service is fantasy until delivered.

The lazy tabloid depiction of U.K. defence spending is also not useful. The government have been attempting to have a fully funded transparent procurement process, rather than previous governments fantasy DIP. Instead of “experts” applauding this they have joined the tabloid chorus line.

1 more comment...

No posts

Ready for more?